True value Icon
Looking for something? Search over 900,000 items in True Value’s warehouse
What Our Customers Say

Always surprised at how much they have here. Like most, I usually travel to Home Depot or Lowe’s for my major home improvement projects. However, I’ve found that more often than not I can find many of the supplies I need right here in town and at a fair price. I actually purchased a great snowblower here a couple of years ago which has served me well. The staff is helpful, so I can get in, get what I need and get back to my project in minutes instead of hours. Oh yeah, Benjamin Moore paints. I’m a regular, I would recommend you give it a try.


VERY IMPRESSED ! I am a frugal educated shopper and after going to several big box stores and other Brinkmann hardware stores looking for help deciding between 2 high priced snow blower models I was blown away by the patience and courtesy extended to me after I asked one complex technical question after another. I was particularly impressed with Chris’ knowledge and professionalism. In today’s world of mediocre employees it was a pleasure dealing with exceptional ones, thank you. I left confident I chose the right model and the right hardware store.

Blue Point

On the phone they were professional. Not pushy about the extended warranty. Delivered promptly and explained snow blower without rushing. Thank you!

Blue Point

The salesman was extremely helpful. Snowblower was delivered next day and that person also went over how to use it. Excellent customer service.

Blue Point

In need of a new snow blower of better quality than the one i now own i decided to shop on the internet and found the product i was looking for was carried locally at the Miller Place Brinkmann’s, I stopped by on Monday and was pleasantly surprised that they had all the available modelsi was considering on display . I was assisted by Dave D. who answered all my questions and concerns and advised me that if i was interested i could have the blower set up and delivered that afternoon at no extra charge. No pressure, no stress and best of all the delivery was made on time and as promised. I should also note that the delivery man Quinton was able to navigate his truck up a difficult driveway and did a walk thru of the blowers features. Very professional! In all, a pleasant experience with two outstanding employeesThus 5 Stars. I hope to be as fortunate with the snow blower when the time comes—–

Mike L
Miller Place

Gary and Ron were great. I called up looking for an Ariens snowblower, and needed it that day before we were expected to receive significant snowfall in New York. I was able to pay over the phone and my new snowblower was delivered to my house in a few hours. The delivery driver’s were also great, however I can not remember their names. They showed me all of the features of the snowblower, and had it up and running for me, ready to go for the storm. This was my first purchase at Brinkmann’s, but you have earned a customer for life. Thanks again!

Tom V

Hardware & Paint Store in Sayville, NY  Google_Plus Google-Maps-icon

Sayville hardware store - brinkmanns

When you’re out and about in Sayville, NY, looking for a friendly neighborhood hardware store, make sure to stop by Brinkmann’s Hardware! We offer knowledgeable and personalized service, helping connect you to the tools and resources you need to accomplish whatever task you’ve set out to do. Whether you’re a DIY enthusiast seeking advice on your next project or renovation, or you’re a professional contractor looking for the best tools and equipment, we’ve got it all and we’re here to assist you.

We’re also the place to go when you need a high-quality paint store in Sayville. We’ve assembled a wealth of knowledge and expertise in paint and paint supplies over the years, and we’ll be more than happy to share all we know with you to keep your interiors and exteriors bright and fresh. We carry premium paints and supplies at affordable prices, so you don’t have to spend all your hard-earned money to make your home look beautiful!

benjamin moore logo

We Are Benjamin Moore Authorized Retailers

Brinkmann’s True Value in Sayville is dedicated to providing you with the highest level of quality, which is why we’re proud to call ourselves an authorized retailer of Benjamin Moore paints. As one of the nation’s most widely recognized brands, Benjamin Moore continues to innovate and produce some of the world’s most durable and vibrant interior and exterior paints and stains.

You’ll be hard pressed to find better prices or a better selection. Our paint is purchased directly from the manufacturer and the savings are passed onto our customers. We’ve got the biggest selection of Benjamin Moore paints on Long Island and our prices on paint applicators are fantastic too.

Whether you’re looking for something new and exciting for a home remodeling project or simply want to match an existing paint color for minor repairs, our extensive selection of Benjamin Moore paint colors is sure to have something beautiful. We’ll send you home with paint samples to test your chosen shades before you make the final purchase. The friendly staff at our Benjamin Moore stores would also be happy to walk you through the steps of preparation and application, as well as help you gather the tools you’ll need to get the job done right.

Dedicated to Energy Efficiency

Aerial Shot of Brinkmann Hardware Sayville Store

Here at Brinkmann’s, we take our community, and responsibility to it, seriously. That’s why our Sayville store is our second net-zero energy retail location! Through a combination of energy-efficient building practices, LED lighting, solar cells, and more, our retail store produces more energy than it uses, helping our environment and reducing our carbon footprint to less than zero.

226 Railroad Ave
Sayville, NY 11782
Hardware: (631) 567-6879
Paint: (631) 589-2462

Monday – Friday: 7am – 6pm
Saturday: 8am – 6pm
Sunday: 9am – 6pm

Products & Services

  • DIY Help
  • Propane Filling
  • Key Duplication and Cutting
  • Screen Repair
  • Clam Power Clothing


  • Benjamin Moore Paint
  • Paint Mixing
  • Custom Color Matching
  • Wallpaper Department
  • Exclusive Vendor of Old World Mouldings
  • Rēvo Sunglasses
  • Benjamin Moore Paints
  • STIHL Outdoor Power Tools
  • Ariens Snow Blowers
  • Weber Grills
  • Yeti Coolers
  • Big Green Egg Dealer
  • Premium Pet Food
  • Carhartt Clothing
  • Librett Doormats
  • Traeger Pellet Grill Dealer
  • Soda Stream Dealer
  • Better Baseboard Covers